Is Tenacious D Metal?

Published by admin on May 19th, 2012

is tenacious d metalWho doesn’t love Tenacious D? This week, The Greatest Band in the World – Jack Black and Kyle Glass – released their third studio album, Rize of the Fenix. Sure, it’s not as good as their previous albums, but it still makes for a fun listen once or twice. Unlike most comedic musical acts, Tenacious D is capable of producing intricate music that has replay value. Not an easy thing to do.

Though most of Tenacious D’s music is acoustic, their influences are clearly heavy metal. One of their most popular songs is “The Metal” for chrissakes. That they’re parodying the genre is obvious, but it’s out of love. As a result, they’ve earned respect from the metal community; Slipknot’s Corey Taylor even has a Tenacious D tribute band.

Even though they’re not heavy most of the time, can Tenacious D be considered metal? On to the debate…

(more…)


Is Brokencyde Metal?

Published by admin on May 16th, 2012

is brokencyde metalLooking through comments on this blog, I saw one that mocked another poster for believing that Iwrestledabearonce is metal (which I agree with).  The poster said, “Do you think Brokencyde is metal?” I try to keep up on current music, but this was the first I’ve heard of Brokencyde. I did a little reading into them and became intrigued.

They’re nearly universally panned. Thrash Magazine has called Brokencyde “a mockery to the world of music.” I’ve listened to their Guilty Pleasurez album, and I honestly don’t get what all the hate’s about. But I also like LuLu and Waka Flocka Flame, so pay me no mind.  Cracked.com calls them a “Slipknot-Cher duet.” 

Slipknot is metal; Cher isn’t. So, is Brokencyde metal? On to the debate.

(more…)


Is Shadows Fall Metal?

Published by admin on May 16th, 2012

is shadows fall metalThis week, Shadows Fall released its seventh studio album, Fire From the Sky. It’s the band’s first album in three years. Early reviews have been positive. James Zalucky of Metal Injection praised the band for remaining “relevant and strong in 2012.” If there was any doubt about this, he wrote, “Shadows Fall has set it ablaze with Fire From the Sky.”

Shadows Fall is clearly marketed as heavy metal band. Being 30+, I’m not sure which demographic they appeal to these days. I first heard of them in the late 1990s or early 2000s, when they were clumped in with the nu metal set. Then they were packaged with metalcore acts like Killswitch Engage and Hatebreed. I don’t think this is entirely fair, either, but it certainly beats the nu metal affiliation.

Hats off to Shadows Fall for keeping up for as long as they have. But can they be considered heavy metal? On to the debate.

(more…)


Is Marilyn Manson Metal?

Published by admin on May 15th, 2012

is marilyn manson metalIt’s been a long time since Marilyn Manson has ruffled anyone’s feathers. The religious right doesn’t seem to care much about him these days, and he’s no longer the go-to media scapegoat. In 2012 and at 43, he’s just not relevant with the today’s youth. He’s probably a few years away from being labeled classic rock. Regardless, he’s never ditched his goth ways and continues putting out new music.

He might not be the Hot Topic superstar he was over a decade ago, but he’s far from washed up. His latest album, Born Villain, has gotten lots of positive reviews from critics and reached the Billboard Top 10. He even convinced Johnny Depp – who doesn’t love him? – to do a duet of Carly Simon’s “You’re So Vain” for the album’s bonus track.

Maybe it’s because of his ridiculous exterior, but Marilyn Manson has never gotten the credit he truly deserves. His talent is undeniable, but is Marilyn Manson heavy metal? On to the debate…

(more…)


Are The Beastie Boys Metal?

Published by admin on May 11th, 2012

beastie boys heavy metalR.I.P. to Adam Yauch AKA MCA of the Beastie Boys, who succumbed to cancer last week at the way-too-young age of 47. The Beastie Boys had an amazing career that spanned three decades. Even though they were well into middle-age, the Beasties still had plenty to give to the music world, which they proved with last year’s underrated gem, Hot Sauce Committee Part Two. Hopefully, there’s some unreleased Beasties gold in a vault somewhere that we’ll hear soon.

MCA, Ad-Rock and Mike D experimented with damn near every genre of music, from hip hop to hardcore punk to jazz to, yes, heavy metal.  In fact, their first album, Licensed to Ill, features solo guitar work by Slayer’s Kerry King.  The metal god, who says he thought the Beasties were cool when he met them, even makes an appearance in the video for the group’s most popular song, “Fight for Your Right to Party.”

So, can the Beastie Boys in any shape or form be considered metal? On to the debate…

(more…)


Are the Foo Fighters Metal?

Published by admin on May 7th, 2012

are the foo fighters metal?During the 2012 Grammy Awards, Foo Fighters leadman David Grohl wore a vintage Slayer t-shirt for multiple performances. The 43-year-old veteran rocker, whois managed to overshadow his time as Nirvana’s drummer, is clearly influenced by the metal genre.

For his 2004 solo project, Probot, Grohl collaborated with an array of heavy metal royalty, including King Diamond, Max Calavera of Sepultura/Soulfly and Lemmy of Motorhead. When asked to name his favorite metal songs, Grohl proved that he knows his stuff; he picked tracks by Iron Butterfly, Judas Priest, Exodus, Trouble, the Melvins, Metal Church, Voivod, Sepultura and Slayer.

No one’s debating whether Grohl or his bandmates love the metal genre, but can the Foo Fighters be considered metal? On to the debate…

(more…)


Is Opeth Metal?

Published by admin on September 20th, 2011

If you’re a die-hard metalhead, you may be disappointed by Opeth’s latest album, Heritage, which was released this week by Roadrunner Records. The album is rather folky and features none of the band’s signature death growls. It’s a lot more in line with 1970s prog rock than metal, but there are still some heavy elements sporadically. If Gentle Giant had been influenced by metal, the new Opeth is what they might sound like.

Not that this is a bad thing. I’ve grown to love prog rock, and I always appreciate it when bands try to venture out of their comfort zones – even if the music they produce doing so doesn’t gel with me. I still have to give Heritage another listen or two to make up my mind, but I did find it enjoyable. Listen to it with an open mind and you just might like it. If you’re one of the rare people who only likes loud music, then don’t bother.

Say what you want about Heritage, but that album cover (pictured above) is definitely metal. It might be the coolest cover I’ve seen all year. Either that or Crowbar’s Sever the Wicked Hand, a no-holds-barred metal album. But you can’t just an album by its cover, so on to the debate: Is Opeth metal?

(more…)


Is The Pretty Reckless Metal?

Published by admin on September 17th, 2011

If you’ve been listening to mainstream rock radio lately, you’ve likely heard The Pretty Reckless’s catchy tune, “Make Me Wanna Die.” I can’t be the only one who was surprised to learn that the band’s female singer is just 18 years old. Taylor Momsen’s voice sounds at least 25, and the subject matter is a bit edgier than what her peers in her age group (Odd Future Wolf Gang Kill Them All excluded) sing about.

With just one album released so far, 2010′s Light Me Up, The Pretty Reckless has already made quite a name for themselves. They’ve shared the stage with several metal acts, including Bullet for My Valentine, Disturbed, Biohazard and Suicide Silence at this year’s Download Festival. At the very least, The Pretty Reckless is hard rock, but can they also be considered metal? On to the debate

(more…)


Is Hollywood Undead Metal?

Published by admin on September 2nd, 2011

Hollywood Undead is a Los Angeles-based band that has a cult following. People over age 25 don’t get it, but they appear to have a strong connection with the Hot Topic crowd. Their two albums – 2008′s Swan Songs and 2011′s American Tragedy – have been panned by critics, but they’ve sold better than anyone expected.

Though the band’s six members don masks, their music is not nearly as heavy as Gwar’s or Slipknot’s. Stylistically, they’re a mix of alternative rock, emo, hip hop and electronica. The music’s not anywhere near as menacing as their masks suggest. But that doesn’t mean they’re not metal. There are plenty of wimpy metal artists out there (Dave Mustaine, anyone?). So, can Hollywood Undead be considered a metal band? On to the debate.
(more…)


Is Warrant Metal?

Published by admin on August 15th, 2011

is warrant heavy metal?Rest in peace to Jani Lane, the Warrant frontman who was found dead in a Woodland Hills, California hotel room last week. He was only 47. A cause of death has not yet been released. If you came of age in the 1980s, you’re probably familiar with Warrant’s music. Even if you’re a 90s baby, odds are you’ve heard “Cherry Pie” at least a few dozen times.

Warrant, founded in 1984, epitomized glam rock. They had super catchy songs, questionable attire and music videos full of eye candy. Hardcore metalheads tend to hate on glam metal. It’s never been my cup of tea, but I understand its appeal. A lot of glam rock bands – Warrant included – are very talented. But can Warrant be considered a heavy metal band? News reports about Lane’s death categorize the band as metal, but the mainstream media aren’t exactly reliable sources on the genre. It’s up to the fans to decide. On to the debate.

(more…)


Switch to our mobile site